A developer that disputes its Batch Zero classification at ERCOT has 35 days to file a complaint at PUCT, and on Nov. 19 the Commission dismissed two complaints dated one day past that limit. It made no exception for the developers, Mesquite H2 and ACS DC Hicks Field Road. Chairman Thomas Gleeson raised both dismissals at the Thursday open meeting. Three other complaints continue.

Batch Zero is ERCOT's process for studying large loads together. ERCOT sorts each project as base load, which it plans to give its full requested transmission capacity, or studied load, which may receive less and cannot energize before Jan. 1, 2028. A developer that disagrees with a studied-load label can complain to PUCT. The 35 days start on the ERCOT conduct it disputes, or at the end of ERCOT's alternative dispute resolution process. For these cases, Gleeson's Nov. 18 memo treats ERCOT's waiver of that process as its completion.

Mesquite H2: day 35 fell on Oct. 19

Mesquite H2 is the developer of Batch Zero project BZ-17. Gleeson said ERCOT acted on Sept. 14, so day 35 was Oct. 19. The complaint is dated Oct. 20 on the PUCT's Interchange filing system, and he put the time at 8:36 a.m. A Mesquite H2 filing acknowledges the Oct. 19 deadline, he said. Mesquite H2 says it filed the day before and that the filing was not processed until the next day. On his reading of the Commission's rules, the filer is responsible for any processing delay.

"My thought is this complaint probably needs to be dismissed," Gleeson said, and he asked for the views of the two lawyers on the Commission. One commissioner said the rule is specific. "I know there might be people that are in disagreement with how the rule's written," that commissioner said, "but that's not the time to have that disagreement." Another said: "We need to be consistent." The commissioners voted by voice, and no count was announced.

On Gleeson's reading, a developer carries the risk that the Interchange date falls after day 35.

ACS DC Hicks Field Road: day 35 fell on Oct. 21

ACS DC Hicks Field Road is the developer of a Fort Worth project on Hicks Field Road. Gleeson said ERCOT acted on Sept. 16, so day 35 was Oct. 21. The complaint is dated Oct. 22. The Commission received no filing that explained the delay, he said.

A commissioner credited Commissioner Kathleen Jackson's point about being consistent and noted that these are cases of "first impression," with no earlier ruling to follow. Each of the other commissioners agreed to dismiss, and the Commission dismissed the complaint by voice vote.

No written order is on the Interchange docket for either case as of Nov. 20. The Commission did not say whether either dismissal bars refiling, or whether either developer has another route to challenge its classification.

Three complaints continue

The Commission then took up the complaints of three other developers together: Medina County Power NR I, which proposes the Medina Technology Park; Rowan Stampede, the developer of Project Stampede in Temple; and Skybox Datacenters, the developer of a Wichita Falls project. Gleeson's memo covers all five cases, and he summarized it for these three. The Commission took no vote on it, and Gleeson said no action was needed. Until the Commission issues an order, the memo is the chairman's recommendation, and commissioners voiced agreement with it.

The memo would deny all four of ERCOT's procedural requests: a generic docket for common questions, a complaint deadline, and limits on discovery and on hearing time. It would also decline, at this time, to suspend ERCOT's conduct, which would freeze a classification while a case runs. ERCOT told the Commission that a studied-load classification does not harm a project during the first phase of Batch Zero, which is not expected to end before the close of March 2027. That statement is why the memo sets March 31 as the target to resolve the cases and why it finds no irreparable harm now. A complainant may ask for emergency relief again if a case cannot finish before the Batch Zero milestone that affects it.

The memo repeats the deadline rule: the 35-day limit "should be strictly enforced," and Gleeson is "prepared to dismiss complaints that fail to meet that deadline." It adds a warning for developers who use ERCOT's six-month window to request dispute resolution. They "may find that by the time they file a complaint at the Commission, the Commission will be unable to grant them the relief they seek."

One commissioner said: "It's important that we take the time and that we treat these separately and follow our rules." Another said that while Batch Zero "may seem glacial for some, it's moved pretty quickly in the administrative process," and hoped the parties would align so the Commission can "hit the March deadline." Gleeson said that where cases share similar issues, efficiency may call for consolidating them, which his memo does not rule out. The three cases are paused on the docket until Nov. 30 unless the parties agree to resume sooner, and the Commission will hold the hearings itself.

What ERCOT and PUCT staff filed Nov. 19

Commission counsel asked the parties on Nov. 5 to file lists of the issues each case must decide. ERCOT filed one list on Nov. 19, captioned in all five dockets. It names seven threshold questions, many of them about ERCOT's Planning Guide, its rulebook for large loads. It also asks the Commission to rule three subjects out of scope for every case:

- Emergency relief that would change a project's classification to base load. ERCOT calls that relief "improper under Texas law."

- Claims that the classification is a retroactive law or impairs a contract under the Texas Constitution.

- Whether a large load or its transmission provider can run its own restudy after the fact to change ERCOT's decision.

Gleeson's memo is narrower on the first point. It would deny emergency relief at this time and leave the door open to a renewed request.

Commission staff in PUCT's Market Analysis Division filed lists of issues in the three continuing dockets. They see two questions common to all three. The first is whether ERCOT may judge the completeness and validity of a project's existing interconnection studies using a different study area than the one the study used. The second is whether the Planning Guide creates an enforceable duty to consult the transmission provider when ERCOT finds a problem with a study.

ERCOT's winter forecast waits on the large-load process

In the same meeting, ERCOT asked for a good cause exception to a Dec. 1 rule deadline. The rule requires ERCOT to file an updated magnitude value for the third part of the Commission's reliability standard for the ERCOT region. ERCOT builds that value from a winter peak forecast and from transmission operators' estimates of the load they could rotate off in an emergency. ERCOT said delays in the large-load process leave it unable to give operators an official winter forecast. It asked for an extension to the second quarter of 2027 and told the Commission "there will be no impact to reliability," because the standard serves long-range planning only. Commission staff agreed, and the Commission approved the order.

Dates in the record

- Nov. 30: The pause on the three continuing cases ends, unless the parties agree to resume sooner.

- March 31, 2027: Gleeson's target for resolving the continuing cases. The Commission did not set a hearing schedule at the meeting.

What is the 35th day on your filing?

Open the Texas map → HyperscaleNews.com/map · Claim a free issue →

Watch the meeting

Watch the Nov. 19 open meeting: youtube.com/watch?v=9-CJ3uk4iw8. The Mesquite H2 item starts at 2:09:50, the Hicks Field Road item at 2:12:28, the Medina, Stampede and Skybox items at 2:14:07, and ERCOT's reliability exception at 2:18:08.

Sources

- PUCT open meeting recording, Nov. 19, 2026

- Chairman Gleeson's memorandum, Nov. 18, 2026, in 60431 Item 25

- ERCOT's list of issues, Nov. 19, 2026, in 60431 Item 26, filed in each of the five dockets

- Commission staff's list of issues, Nov. 19, 2026, in 60431 Item 28, with matching filings in 60356 and 60396

- Docket numbers: Mesquite H2, 60410; ACS DC Hicks Field Road, 60425; Medina County Power NR I, 60356; Rowan Stampede, 60396; Skybox Datacenters, 60431.

- Filing dates for the two dismissed complaints come from the Interchange docket indexes. Item 1 in 60410 is dated Oct. 20, 2026, and Item 1 in 60425 is dated Oct. 22, 2026.